Matt Cutts, leader of Google’s Webspam Team, set off a maelstrom earlier in the week with a post from his personal blog entitled:
“The Decay and Fall of Guest Blogging.” He later revised the title to: The Decay and Fall of Guest Blogging for SEO.
Obviously, when Matt says something the SEO community pays attention. Unfortunately, Matt shoots from the hip occasionally and generalizes his comments on guest posting causing a great deal of confusion. The original post and title is another example.
To Matt’s credit he responded to the 400+ comments with a follow up guest post (yes – a guest post!) with examples, a bit of self deprecation and much needed clarity. See link below.
I’m a big believer in the value of guest blogging as a strategy to build your brand, reach a larger, incremental audience and bring referrals to your site. And it has great SEO value if natural links are provided by the publisher.
Sorting Through it All
Since Matt’s post I’ve spent a great deal of time sorting through the SEO community’s reaction and interpretation of Matt’s post and comments. Below is my recap to save you the trouble.
Guest Posting Needs to Stand On Its Own as a Marketing Strategy
Quality guest posting is an important strategy for brands and online marketers if done well. In Cutts’ revised post he says, “There are still many good reasons to do some guest blogging (exposure, branding, increased reach, community, etc.). Those reasons existed way before Google and they’ll continue into the future. I don’t want to throw the baby out with the bathwater.”
For starters, don’t do guest posting if you are only after the “follow” links for SEO. Guest posting should stand on its own as a strategy. Neil Patel put it well when he said to do it in order to “drive traffic, increase sales, and grow your brand”. It’s better to do a guest post at a highly trafficked, relevant site without the follow, than a site with a smaller audience and the benefit of passing PageRank with a follow.
Some marketers are discounting the benefit of referral traffic where links are not followed. Imagine a site that has 50,000 unique visitors. Some will share the post and amplify the brand exposure, others will go to your site, sign up for your enewsletter, follow you and spend time reviewing your offering and your content. If they like what they see, you could earn a direct link from that visitor and additional shared content. All this from a nofollow link!
Bloggers and guest author’s should build a relationship of trust and should understand who they are collaborating with. You don’t want outgoing links from your site to one that is irrelevant and of poor quality. Likewise you don’t want to be guest posting and promoting your brand on a site that may be under Google’s scrutiny or hit by a future algorithm update.
Expect Publishers to Tighten Their Guest Post Guidelines
Publishers see quality guest blogging as a way to scale relevant content and introduce new topics to their audience. However, they will be more cautious in the future and will use “nofollow” tags frequently and integrate it into their guest post guidelines to avoid potential penalties. Although you may not get PageRank from your post, you’ll have all the other benefits of the post (new audience, referral traffic, social shares).
The Rise Of Social Signals and Author Rank
Many experts are predicting that Google will put more emphasis on social signals and Google Author Rank to measure the quality of the author’s content and site authority. Lots of social shares are a vote for your content. Stay tuned.
“Stick a Fork in it” – Matt Cutts. Below Are Guest Post Practices That Put You at Risk.
Developing and distributing high volume, low quality posts created solely or mainly for SEO is spammy.
“Irrelevant posts” on “irrelevant sites” evidenced by shallow thin content and links to pages that don’t add value to the reader.
Too much rich anchor text links to the author’s properties. It doesn’t look natural.
Massive campaigns to get guest posts.
Offering money for posts.
Want More? Below are Three Insightful Posts On the State of Guest Blogging
SEO 2.0′s “Guest Post by Matt Cutts on Spammy Link Building” – Matt’s guest post attempts to make it “unmistakeably clear that guest blogging is not bad by definition.”…”Only low quality guest posting solely or mainly for SEO purposes is spammy”. Matt’s goal, “It’s about cleaning up the Web.”
Neil Patel’s post – Guest Posting and SEO – A Match Still Made In Heaven Takeaways:
“…my prediction is that guest posting will help with your rankings…just not the way you think it may.”
“Link to your own website only when it is relevant and benefits the reader.”
Search Engine Watch’s Jennifer Slegg, “Matt Cutts Says ‘Stop’ Guest Blogging for SEO: Here’s Everything You Need to Know”
“Many people simply forget that the success of a link, regardless of whether it is nofollowed or not, can also be measured in how much direct traffic that link generates.”
I’ll keep this post updates as more comes out on the important topic of guest posting. In the meantime, happy guest posting!
image source : searchengineland.com